Order Pies Online


Spring is upon us and we think one of the best ways to welcome the extra sunshine is a fresh-baked pie. Perfect for giving, entertaining, celebrating… and breakfast!

Our busy baking team requires three days advance notice for online pies, so your order needs to be completed 72 hours prior to your selected pickup date.

Enter any special notes and prep details on the checkout page. We’ve capped it at 10 pies per order online, but you can order as many as you wish if you give us a call or stop by!

Need Help or Something Special? Call 970.233-PIES (7437)

Cherry Pie

So pretty and so, so good. Flaky lattice crust bursting with sweet/tart cherries. Perfect served warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

Apple Pie

Flaky double crust pie filled with enchanting spices and three varieties of apples - Gala, Pink Lady and Granny Smith. Eleven apples in every pie!

Raspberry Swirled Cheesecake Pie

Dense and delicious New York style cheesecake filling is swirled with raspberries and baked in a graham cracker crust.

Buttermilk Berry Pie

Tangy buttermilk and sweet berries baked together in a vanilla wafer crust and garnished with fluffy whipped cream.

Quadruple Coconut Cream Pie

Our best seller, a filling of coconut cream and coconut milk, shredded coconut in the crust and toasted coconut on top of whipped cream.

Banana Cream Pie

Vanilla cookie crust layered with white chocolate, banana pudding, bananas, more vanilla cookies and topped with whipped cream and white chocolate curls.

Cold Brewed Coffee Cream Pie

A chocolate cookie crust holds a luscious filling of cold brewed coffee pastry cream sweetened with white chocolate then topped with coffee infused whipped cream.

Cookies & Cream Pie

A must have! Chocolate Oreo pastry cream fills a flaky butter crust, which is topped with cookies & cream whipped cream and more cookie crumbles.

Vegan Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

A vegan chocolate cookie crust coated in a dark chocolate coconut ganache, then filled with rich peanut butter mousse and topped with whipped coconut cream with crunchy toasted coconut and chocolate pearls to garnish. Creamy, dreamy and full of peanut flavor!

Nutella Caramel Corn Pie

Rich Nutella-infused custard is baked in a chocolate crust and topped with a chocolaty Nutella glaze and caramel drizzle. To top it all off, house-made caramel corn garnishes the pie with a salty crunch!

Individual Pavlova Pie (GF)

Naturally gluten-free baked meringue crust is filled with lemon curd and garnished with a bevy of beautiful, seasonal fruit and berries. (Served as individual portions.)

Seasonal Veggie Quiche

Flaky crust filled with flavorful, seasonal vegetables and cheeses within a rich egg custard.

Sourdough Bread

This chewy, crusty loaf is fast becoming a cult favorite here at Ginger and Baker. Some like it toasted so they can fill all the nooks and crannies with butter. Others swear it makes the best sandwich in the land. Each 2 pound loaf, has 12-18 slices, and makes 6-8 sandwiches, or lasts for 1 car ride home. 

Wooden Pie Box

Perfect for gift-giving, travel or as a keepsake, order your pie with its own pie box!
Allergen Disclaimer: peanuts, tree-nuts, gluten, dairy, eggs, and soy are all present in the kitchen.